74°
Baton Rouge, Louisiana
7 Day Forecast
Follow our weather team on social media

Judge to rule Monday if charges will be dismissed for man accused of raping Madison Brooks

15 minutes 24 seconds ago Thursday, November 19 2026 Nov 19, 2026 November 19, 2026 2:23 PM November 19, 2026 in News
Source: WBRZ

BATON ROUGE - Lawyers for a man accused of raping LSU student Madison Brooks on the night of her death argued in court Thursday that charges against him should be dismissed due to Nancy Grace discussing critical evidence in the case. 

Attorney Caitlin Fowlkes, who represents Desmond Carter, filed a motion asking 19th JDC Judge Gail Horne Ray to either dismiss the first- and third-degree rape charges against her client or exclude evidence from being used during the trial.

Carter's attorney claimed that increased media attention on the case, including the national series "Crime Stories with Nancy Grace," means any panel of jurors "may have already accepted a well-known attorney and TV personality's opinion of the truth," she said.

In an episode posted Oct. 29, Grace discussed the ongoing case with Brooks' mother Ashley Baustert and other commentators. While speaking to psychoanalyst Dr. Bethany Marshall, Grace mentioned that they both had seen a video of a "sex attack" on Brooks.

"It's on video for Pete's sake. You and I have both seen the video. It's horrible," Grace said.

The episode was posted on multiple platforms and, after two weeks, has YouTube 156,000 views.

During Thursday's hearing, Fowlkes said the videos Grace claimed to have seen are protected evidence in the case. She said that Grace's comments about them has the "potential to compromise the fairness of the proceedings."

Fowlkes claimed that potential jurors would be walking into the jury selection process with a "public perception that Mr. Carter is guilty."

She said the clips would only have been leaked to the TV host either directly or indirectly through the district attorney's office. She said that, five weeks out from trial, Carter's attorneys have not seen them.

However, an assistant district attorney pointed to a 2023 press conference held by lawyer Joe Long, who is representing Casen Carver, another defendant. He and disbarred attorney Ron Haley told WBRZ they viewed the footage from that night and believed it would disprove the police's version of events.

According to law enforcement, Brooks met Carter, Carver, Kaivon Washington and Everett Lee at Reggie's Bar in Tigerland on Jan. 15, 2023. The WBRZ Investigative Unit obtained video of Brooks running through the parking lot and across the road to leave with the group. Police say Carver drove them to a parking lot where Carter and Washington took turns having sex with Brooks.

The men reportedly told officers that Brooks then requested to go home and gave them multiple wrong addresses before she asked to be dropped off at the front of the Pelican Lakes subdivision, where she wandered onto Burbank Drive and in front of a car. A coroner's report said Brooks' BAC was .319 and she had physical injuries consistent with rape when she died.

Following her death, Carter, who was 17 at the time, allegedly texted the other men that he'd been advised by his mother not to talk about the case. The text messages became public after they were included in a filing by the DA's office.

Carter’s lawyers asked Judge Horne Ray to dismiss the case or exclude the video and text message evidence. Fowlkes said that while moving the trial to another parish may work in other cases, juries in other areas are likely to be prejudiced due to the publicity.

"A change of venue doesn't work when you're talking about national news," Fowlkes said.

Judge Horne Ray said she will make a ruling on Monday. Carter’s trial is set for Dec. 7.

More News

Desktop News

Click to open Continuous News in a sidebar that updates in real-time.
Radar
7 Days